Society and relationships · 2 min read

Showing that you helped others brought more yeses to hosting requests

Study-created profiles with references describing help received more immediate yeses on an online hospitality network. Neutral praise drew fewer acceptances.

How we make these readings

The study, in plain language

The team created eight profiles for an online hospitality community using names and photos of real people who gave permission. Some profiles described the person as having helped others. The rest had equally positive references, but described a friendship without that helping experience. The team designed the text, and ten existing community members posted references following instructions. Researchers then randomly assigned which profile sent each lodging request.

Requests with a history of helping received more immediate acceptances and more responses in an analysis adjusted for other factors. In a separate, non-randomized analysis, researchers compared whether prospective hosts with more references indicating that they had received hospitality accepted more requests. They found no such association. There are limits: only eight profiles, with different photos, were used, and community administrators ended the study early. The results do not show what drove each response or whether a yes led to an actual stay.

The key idea

A concrete history of helping mattered more than general praise, at least in this online community.

Something to think about

When you read a recommendation, what carries more weight: general praise or something specific the person did for others? The study does not show that sharing this history guarantees a place to stay.

The original study

Indirect Reciprocity; A Field Experiment

PLOS ONE. Published .

Study authors (2)

Jacobien van Apeldoorn, Arthur Schram

DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0152076

Source under CC BY 4.0. English adaptation and explanation by PaperFlow, with AI assistance. The text has been reorganized for a general audience; it is not the complete paper and does not imply endorsement by its authors.

One study alone does not represent a field's consensus. Educational content does not replace professional advice. Report a possible error.